Notes on Bass, Drums and Vocal Entrances

What the first two seconds of a clip usually tell you, instrument by instrument.

When a clip is only a few seconds long, the information is concentrated at the start. This is where my notes have been the most useful, because they describe the same two seconds over and over from different angles.

Bass is the most reliable identifier in my experience and the one I use least. The note choices are more personal to an era than the tone: a walking line in the first bar says something different from a root note held under the whole phrase. When I remember to listen to the bass first, my guesses improve immediately.

Drums tell you more about production than about the song. A gated snare, a dry snare and a snare loud enough to mask the vocal are three different decades even when the pattern is identical. The hi-hat pattern is the other giveaway, and it is almost never the thing I notice first.

Vocal entrances are the hardest and the most rewarding. Where the voice comes in, and what it does in the half-second before the first word, is a fingerprint. A singer who begins on the downbeat and a singer who lets the band breathe first can be the same person in the same year, but they never sound the same in a two-second clip.

The way to build these notes is to copy them after every round. I use three columns in a plain file. When there is no round, I browse past songs and fill the same columns from the answer page. It is the least glamorous habit here and it works the best. Play daily for a month and you will have your own three columns.

I listen to the first two seconds on purpose now, and the habit cost me the first year of playing. The reason is simple: the opening two seconds are where the game puts its information, and most of us start listening in the middle of the clip because we are not ready yet. My fix was mechanical. After pressing play, I tap the pause key on the second listen and sit with the very first moment. It is a strange way to listen to a song and a very effective way to hear a clip. The instrument that opens the recording is not always the answer, but it is rarely a coincidence.

← Hearing the Difference Between Two Decades · What Sticks After the Song Ends →