The single most common mistake in my notes is a decade error: right genre, wrong era by about eight years. It is a deeply annoying mistake because the correct answer is often a song I know well, and I simply placed it in the wrong room.
The cues that help me most are not the ones people expect. Instruments are unreliable: a drum machine from 1983 and a drum machine from 1999 can be the same box. What changes is the way the recording is put together. Reverb that sits on everything, including the vocals, usually means the early 1980s. Dry, close vocals with a very loud kick say late 1980s to mid 1990s. A hi-hat that cuts through the whole mix like a knife is a later habit than most people assume.
Lyrics help less than I hoped. Delivery helps a lot. Singers in different decades use breath differently, and the difference between a final consonant being eaten and being pronounced is often the whole answer.
The way to learn these cues is to guess wrong in writing. When I miss by a decade, I write the cue that fooled me. After a year that list is the most personal page in this notebook. Start guessing tomorrow with a note for the decade you think it is, and the Songless home page becomes a lab where the experiment costs ninety seconds.
There is one more cue that has been surprisingly useful and is completely unmusical: the mix's attitude toward silence. Early decades leave gaps between instruments and let the room be heard. Later production tends to fill every space, and the filling has a date. If I can hear the room, I am usually in an earlier decade than my first guess suggested. If every frequency is occupied, I move forward ten years in my head before I pick a name. This is a rule of thumb, not a law, and my notes contain several exceptions that are more interesting than the rule.
← The Answer Archive as a Listening Syllabus · Notes on Bass, Drums and Vocal Entrances →